Music and Authority in the Reign of Queen Elizabeth I

I was researching musical performances by Queen Elizabeth I (1558-1603) when I stumbled across John Davies’ poem, ‘To the Queen’ in the front of Roy Strong’s The Cult of Elizabeth (p.10).Davies’ poem characterises Elizabeth’s reign though a series of musical metaphors. While there has been extensive research into Elizabeth’s royal image, and while Elizabeth was widely known as a musical monarch (she played the lute, virginals, sang and even claimed to have composed dance music), the role of music in representations of the Queen had received surprisingly little comment, and so I began to look for other examples.

As I looked into musical images of monarchy I found that Elizabeth and those who represented her trod a fine line between music’s connotations of order, rationality and harmonious kingship on the one hand, and connotations of sensuality and the erotic power of female musicians on the other. There were potential problems that might arise for a musical Queen: criticisms of wantonness, frivolity or lack of chastity were not uncommonly levelled at musical women. The dangers had been realised for Elizabeth’s mother, Anne Boleyn, and another of Henry VIII’s wives, Catherine Howard, when supposed affairs with virginal players were among the evidence used to condemn them, while Mary Queen of Scots was criticised for her close relationship to the singer, David Rizzio. In addition, for any monarch metaphors of concord might easily be transformed into ones of discord in times of political turbulence. Yet musical symbolism also offered a means to characterise authority, divine rulership, piety and the stability of the realm, and offered particularly fitting images of Queenship in light of popular notions of the harmonious powers of female musicians in particular. Through combining Elizabeth’s practical musicality with speculative notions of political harmony – and by drawing on ideas of both the rational and sensual powers of music – Elizabeth and her courtiers were able to turn music into an image of female power and authority.

Some of the results of this research (there’s more to come) have recently been published, and as the enlightened editors at Renaissance Quarterly kindly allow authors to post copies of their articles on their personal website, I am able to post a link to an open-access copy here:

Katherine Butler,‘ “By Instruments her Powers Appeare”: Music and Authority in the Reign of Queen Elizabeth I’, Renaissance Quarterly 65 (2012), 353-384


Alciato, Andrea. Emblematum Liber. Augsburg, 1534. [accessed 13/02/2010].

Archer, Ian. The Pursuit of Stability: Social Relations in Elizabethan London. Cambridge, 1991.

Ashbee, Andrew, and David Lasocki. A Biographical Dictionary of English Court Musicians 1485–1715. 2 vols. Aldershot, 1998.

Austern, Linda Phyllis. “‘Sing Againe Syren’: The Female Musician and Sexual Enchantment in Elizabethan Life and Literature.” Renaissance Quarterly 42.3 (1989): 420–48.

_____. “‘Alluring the Auditorie to Effeminacie’: Music and the Idea of the Feminine in Early Modern England.” Music & Letters 74 (1993): 343–54.

_____. “Women’s Musical Voices in Sixteenth-Century England.” Early Modern Women: An Interdisciplinary Journal 3 (2008): 127–52.

Aylmer, John. An Harborowe for Faithfull and Trewe Subiectes Agaynst the Late Blowne Blaste, Concerninge the Gouernment of Wemen. Wherin be Confuted All Such Reasons as a Straunger of Late Made in that Behalfe, with a Breife Exhortation to Obedience. London, 1559.

Bacon, Francis. The Wisedome of the Ancients, Written in Latine by the Right Honourable Sir Francis Bacon Knight, Baron of Verulam and Lord Chancelour of England. Done into English by Sir Arthur Gorges Knight. London, 1619.

_____. The Works of Francis Bacon. Ed. James Spedding, Robert Leslie Ellis, and Douglas Denon Heath. 14 vols. London, 1857–74.

Barnes, Joseph, ed. Speeches Deliuered to Her Maiestie this Last Progresse at the Right Honorable the Lady Russels, at Bissam, the Right Honorable the Lorde Chandos at Sudley, at the Right Honorable the Lord Norris, at Ricorte. Oxford, 1592.

Bates, Catherine. The Rhetoric of Courtship in Elizabethan Language and Literature. Cambridge, 1992.

Berry, Philippa. Of Chastity and Power: Elizabethan Literature and the Unmarried Queen. London, 1989.

Bennet, John. “Elisa Her Name Gives Honor.” In British Library: Add MSS 17786–91, 9v (17790, 5v–6r).

Brewer, J. S., R. H. Brodie, and James Gairdner, eds. Letters and Papers, Foreign and Domestic of the Reign of Henry VIII. 21 vols. London, 1864–1920.

Brink, J. R. “Sir John Davies’s Orchestra: Political Symbolism and Textual Revisions.” Durham University Journal n.s., 41 (1980): 195–201.

Burton, Robert. The Anatomy of Melancholy What It Is. With All the Kindes, Causes, Symptomes, Prognostickes, and Seuerall Cures of It. In Three Maine Partitions with Their Seuerall Sections, Members, and Subsections. Philosophically, Medicinally, Historically, Opened and Cut Vp. By Democritus Iunior. With a Satyricall Preface, Conducing to the Following Discourse. Oxford, 1621.

Byrd, William. Cantiones Sacrae (1575). Ed. Craig Monson. London, 1977.

Calogero, Elena Laura. “‘Sweet aluring harmony’: Heavenly and Earthly Sirens in Sixteenth-Century Literary and Visual Culture.” In Music of the Sirens, ed. Linda Phyllis Austern and Inna Naroditskaya, 140–75. Bloomington, 2006.

Castiglione, Baldassarre. The Courtyer of Count Baldessar Castilio Diuided into Foure Bookes. Very Necessary and Profitable for Yonge Gentilmen and Gentilwomen Abiding in Court, Palaice or Place, Done into English by Thomas Hoby. London, 1561.

Challoner, Francis. “To Sir Thomas Challoner, 18 December 1562.” In Secretaries of State: State Papers Foreign, Elizabeth I, 1558–1577. SP70/66, 92v–96v. The National Archives of the UK. [accessed 26/02/2010].

Chamberlain, John. The Letters of John Chamberlain. Ed. Norman Egbert McClure. Philadelphia, 1939.

Chambers, E. K. The Elizabethan Stage. 4 vols. Oxford, 1945.

Churchyard, Thomas. A Musicall Consort of Heauenly Harmonie (Compounded Out of Manie Parts of Musicke) Called Churchyards Charitie. London, 1595.

Clapham, John. Elizabeth of England: Certain Observations Concerning the Life and Reign of Queen Elizabeth by John Clapham. Ed. Evelyn Plummer Read and Conyers Read. Philadelphia, 1951.

Craig-McFeely, Julia. “The Signifying Serpent: Seduction by Cultural Stereotype in Seventeenth-Century England.” In Music, Sensation and Sensuality, ed. Linda Phyllis Austern, 299–317. London, 2002.

Davidson, Peter, and Jane Stevenson. “Elizabeth I’s Reception at Bisham (1592): Elite Women as Writers and Devisers.” In The Progresses, Pageants, and Entertainments of Queen Elizabeth I, ed. Jayne Elisabeth Archer, Elizabeth Goldring, and Sarah Knight, 207–26. Oxford, 2007.

Davies, Sir John. Hymnes of Astraea in Acrosticke Verse. London, 1599.

_____ The Poems of Sir John Davies. Ed. Robert Krueger. Oxford, 1975.

Doran, Susan. Monarchy and Matrimony: The Courtships of Elizabeth I. London, 1996.

_____ “Three Late-Elizabethan Succession Tracts.” In The Struggle for the Succession (2004), 100–17.

Dowland, John. The Second Booke of Songs or Ayres, of 2. 4. and 5. Parts with Tableture for the Lute or Orpherian, with the Violl de Gamba. Composed by Iohn Dowland Batcheler of Musick, and Lutenist to the King of Denmark: Also an Excelent Lesson for the Lute and Base Viol, Called Dowlands Adew. London, 1600.

Drayton, Michael. Idea the Shepheards Garland Fashioned in Nine Eglogs. Rowlands Sacrifice to the Nine Muses. London, 1593.

Ellis-Fermor, Una. The Frontiers of Drama. 3rd ed. London, 1964.

Elyot, Sir Thomas. The Boke Named the Gouernour, Deuysed by Syr Thomas Elyot Knight. London, 1537.

Evans, Gwynne Blakemore. The Riverside Shakespeare, 2nd ed. Boston, 1997.

Fantazzi, Charles. “Vives, Juan Luis (1492/3–1540).” In Oxford Dictionary of National Biography. Oxford, 2004; online edn, 2008. [accessed 17/02/2009].

Fischlin, Daniel. “The Performance Context of the English Lute Song, 1596–1622.” In Performance on the Lute, Guitar and Vihuela: Historical Practice and Modern Interpretation,ed. Victor Anand Coelho, 47–71. Cambridge, 1997.

Fitzwilliam, William, Earl of Southampton. “About Katharine Howard (5 Nov 1541).” State Papers, Henry VIII: General Series. National Archives of the UK, SP 1/167, 110r–13r. [accessed 23/02/2010].

Fox, Adam. Oral and Literate Culture in England 1500–1700. Oxford, 2000.

Gascoigne, George. The Pleasauntest Workes of George Gascoigne Esquyre newlye compyled into one volume, that is to say: his flowers, hearbes, weedes, the fruites of warre, the comedie called Supposes, the tragedie of Iocasta, the Steele glasse, the complaint of Phylomene, the storie of Ferdinando Ieronimi, and the pleasure at Kenelworth Castle. London, 1587.

Gosson, Stephen. The Schoole of Abuse Conteining a Plesaunt Inuectiue Against Poets, Pipers, Plaiers, Iesters, and Such Like Caterpillers of a Comonwelth; Setting Vp the Hagge of Defiance to their Mischieuous Exercise, Ouerthrowing their Bulwarkes, by Prophane Writers, Naturall Reason, and Common Experience: a Discourse as Pleasaunt for Gentlemen that Fauour Learning, as Profitable for All that Wyll Follow Virtue. London, 1579.

Greene, Thomas. “Magic and Festivity at the Renaissance Court.” Renaissance Quarterly 40.4 (1987): 636–59.

Guy, John. “The 1590s: The Second Reign of Elizabeth I?” In The Reign of Elizabeth I: Court and Culture in the Last Decade, ed. John Guy, 1–19. Cambridge, 1995.

Harington, Sir John. Nugæ Antiquæ: Being a Miscellaneous Collection of Original Papers, in Prose and Verse; Written During the Reigns of Henry VIII, Edward VI, Queen Mary, Elizabeth, and King James. Ed. Henry Harington and Thomas Park. 2 vols. London, 1804.

Helms, Dietrich. “Henry VIII’s Book: Teaching Music to Royal Children.” Musical Quarterly 92 (2009): 118–35.

Herries, Lord. Historical Memoirs of the Reign of Mary Queen of Scots, and a Portion of the Reign of King James the Sixth. Ed. R. Pitcairn. Edinburgh, 1836.

Hollander, John. The Untuning of the Sky: Ideas of Music in English Poetry 1500–1700.Princeton, 1961.

Holman, Peter. Four and Twenty Fiddlers: The Violin at the English Court, 1540–1690. Oxford, 1993.

Hotson, Leslie. The First Night of Twelfth Night. New York, 1954.

Hurstfield, Joel. “The Succession Struggle in Late Elizabethan England.” In Freedom, Corruption and Government in Elizabethan England,ed. Joel Hurstfield, 104–34. London, 1973.

Kelsey, Sean. “Davies, Sir John (bap. 1569, d. 1626).” In Oxford Dictionary of National Biography. Oxford, 2004; online ed., 2008. (accessed 31 March 2009).

Kilroy, Gerard, ed. The Epigrams of Sir John Harington. Farnham, 2009.

Klarwill, Victor, ed. Queen Elizabeth and Some Foreigners: Being a Series of Hitherto Unpublished Letters from the Archives of the Hapsburg Family. London, 1928.

Knox, John. The First Blast of the Trumpet Against the Monstruous Regiment of Women. Geneva, 1558.

Kyffin, Maurice. The Blessednes of Brytaine, or A Celebration of the Queenes Holyday Conteining, a Breefe Rehersall, of the Inestimable Benefits, Generally Had & Enioyed, Not Only All England Ouer, But Also in Forrein Partes, Through the Gracious Bountie, and Incomparable Blessed Rule of Our Royall Queene Elizabeth. Composed, and Set Foorth, in Due Reuerence, & Ioyfull Memoriall, of Her Maiesties Present Entrance into the Thirtieth Yeere of Her Most Triumphant Raigne, with Hartie Prayer, for the Long Continuing, and Prosperous Preseruing of the Same: By Maurice Kyffin. London, 1587.

Landels, John. Music in Ancient Greece and Rome. London, 1999.

Lasocki, David. The Bassanos: Venetian Musicians and Instrument Makers in England, 1531–1665. Aldershot, 1995.

Levin, Carole. The Heart and Stomach of a King: Elizabeth I and the Politics of Sex and Power. Philadelphia, 1994.

_____ The Reign of Elizabeth I. Basingstoke, 2002.

Lloyd, Lodowick. The Pilgrimage of Princes, Penned Out of Sundry Greeke and Latine Aucthours, by Lodowicke Lloid Gent. London, 1573.

Loades, David. Mary Tudor: A Life. Oxford, 1989.

MacCaffrey, Wallace. Elizabeth I: War and Politics, 1588–1603. Princeton, 1992.

de Maisse, André Hurault. A Journal of All That was Accomplished by Monsieur De Maisse, Ambassador in England from King Henri IV to Queen Elizabeth . . . 1597. Ed. Robert Arthur Jones and G. B. Harrison. London, 1931.

Manning, John. “Continental Emblem Books in Sixteenth Century England: The Evidence of Sloane MS. 3794.” Emblematica 1 (1986): 1–11.

_____ “Geffrey Whitney’s Unpublished Emblems: Further Evidence of Indebtedness to Continental Traditions.” In The English Emblem and the Continental Tradition, ed. Peter M. Daly, 83–107. New York, 1988.

_____ “An Unedited and Unpublished Sixteenth-Century English Translation of Some Alciato Emblems: British Library Additional MS. 61822.” Emblematica 7 (1993): 181–82.

Melville, James. Memoirs of Sir James Melville of Halhill, 1535–1617. Ed. A. Francis Steuart. London, 1929.

Montrose, Louis. “‘Shaping Fantasies’: Figurations of Gender and Power in Elizabethan Culture.” Representations 2 (1983): 61–94.

_____ The Subject of Elizabeth: Authority, Gender, and Representation. Chicago, 2006.

Mulcaster, Richard. Positions Wherin those Primitiue Circumstances be Examined, which are Necessarie for the Training Vp of Children, Either for Skill in Their Booke, Or Health in Their Bodie. Written by Richard Mulcaster, Master of the Schoole Erected in London Anno. 1561. in the Parish of Sainct Laurence Powntneie, by the Worshipfull Companie of the Merchaunt Tailers of the Said Citie. London, 1581.

Myers, Nick. “The Gossip of History: The Question of the Succession in the State Papers.” In The Struggle for the Succession (2004), 49–64.

Nichols, John. The Progresses and Public Processions of Queen Elizabeth: Among which are Interspersed other Solemnities, Public Expenditures, and Remarkable Events, during the Reign of that Illustrious Princess. London, 1823.

Peele, George. Anglorum Feriae Englandes Hollydayes Celebrated the 17th Novemb. Last, 1595, Beginning Happyly the 38 Yeare of the Reigne of our Soveraigne Ladie Queene Elizabeth by George Peele Mr of Arte in Oxforde. 1595. Reprint, London, 1840.

Plato. The Republic. Trans. Tom Griffith. Ed. G. R. F. Ferrari. Cambridge, 2000.

Pollack, Janet. “Princess Elizabeth Stuart as Musician and Muse.” In Musical Voices of Early Modern Women: Many-Headed Melodies, ed. Thomasin LaMay, 399–424. Aldershot, 2005.

de Pontaymeri, Alexandre. A Womans Woorth, Defended Against all the Men in the World Proouing them to be More Perfect, Excellent, and Absolute in all Vertuous Actions, then any Man of what Qualitie Soeuer. Written by One that Hath Heard Much, Seene Much, but Knowes a Great Deale More. London, 1599.

Poulton, Diana. “The Favourite Singer of Queen Elizabeth I.” The Consort 14 (1957): 24–27.

_____ John Dowland.London, 1982.

Prizer, William. “Una ‘Virtù Molto Conveniente a Madonna’: Isabella d’Este as a Musician.” The Journal of Musicology 17 (1999): 10–49.

Salomon, Nanette. “Positioning Women in Visual Convention: The Case of Elizabeth I.” In Attending to Women in Early Modern England, ed. Betty Travitsky and Adele F. Seeff, 64–95. Newark, 1994.

Salter, Thomas. A Mirrhor Mete for All Mothers, Matrones, and Maidens, Intituled the Mirrhor of Modestie No Lesse Profitable and Pleasant, Then Necessarie to Bee Read and Practiced. London, 1579.

Saslow, James. The Medici Wedding of 1589: Florentine Festival as Theatrum Mundi. New Haven, 1996.

Shakespeare, William. Troilus and Cressida. Ed. Anthony Dawson. Cambridge, 2003.

Sharpe, Kevin. Selling the Tudor Monarchy: Authority and Image in Sixteenth Century England. New Haven, 2009.

Smith, Jeremy. “Music and Late Elizabethan Politics: The Identities of Oriana and Diana.” Journal of the American Musicological Society 58 (2005): 507–58.

The Speeches and Honorable Entertainment Giuen to the Queenes Maiestie in Progresse, at Cowdrey in Sussex, by the Right Honorable the Lord Montacute.London, 1591.

Spenser, Edmund. The Shepheardes Calender Conteyning Twelue Aeglogues Proportionable to the Twelue Monethes. Entitled to the Noble and Vertuous Gentleman Most Worthy of All Titles Both of Learning and Cheualrie M. Philip Sidney. London, 1579.

Spring, Matthew. The Lute in Britain: A History of the Instrument and its Music. Oxford, 2001.

Stevenson, Joseph, et al., eds. Calendar of State Papers Foreign, Elizabeth 1558–1589. London, 1863–1950.

The Struggle for the Succession in Late Elizabethan England: Politics, Polemics and Cultural Representations. Ed. Jean-Christophe Mayer. Montpellier, 2004.

Strong, Roy. The Cult of Elizabeth: Elizabethan Portraiture and Pageantry. London, 1977.

_____ The English Renaissance Miniature. London, 1983.

Treitler, Leo, ed. Strunk’s Source Readings in Music History. New York, 1998.

van Orden, Kate. Music, Discipline and Arms in Early Modern France. Chicago, 2005.

Vives, Juan Luis. A Verie Fruitfull and Pleasant Booke, Called the Instruction of a Christian Woman. Made First in Latin, by the Right Famous Cleark M. Lewes Viues, and Translated out of Latine into Englishe, by Richard Hyrde. 8th ed. London, 1585.

Wegman, Rob. The Crisis of Music in Early Modern Europe 1470–1530. New York, 2005.

Wells, Robin Headlam. Elizabethan Mythologies: Studies in Poetry, Drama and Music. Cambridge, 1994.

Württemberg, Frederick, Duke of, and Prince Lewis Frederick. England as Seen by Foreigners in the Days of Elizabeth and James the First, Comprising Translations of the Journals of the Two Dukes of Wirtemberg [Frederick I and Prince Lewis Frederick] in 1592 and 1610. Ed. William Brenchley Rye. London, 1865.

Young, Alan. Tudor and Jacobean Tournaments. London, 1987.

Zecher, Carla. The Gendering of the Lute in Sixteenth-Century French Love Poetry.” Renaissance Quarterly 53.3 (2000): 769–91.


One thought on “Music and Authority in the Reign of Queen Elizabeth I

  1. Pingback: Music and Authority in the Reign of Queen Elizabeth I | lauraleighlinker

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s